The Best Scar Removal Cream - 2017 Reviews and Top Picks

“In our commitment to help you get flawless and younger-looking skin, we’ve come up with this list of the best scar removal creams out of more than 20 top performing brands today. They were selected based on their ability to reduce scar appearance, facilitate repair and the additional skin benefits they after 18 hours of hard work and reviewing.”

At A Glance: Our Choices for The Best Scar Removal Creams

Promising results in just 14 days, Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream has dimethicones, antioxidants and peptides to help your skin be at its best condition. It has a light consistency that works really well for new scars.

Evanesce Advanced Scar and Blemish Treatment can work on almost all types of scars- acne, surgical and even stretch marks. It utilizes the power of natural plant extracts along with specific vitamins to help make your skin look more flawless and clearer.

For a paraben-free option to scar removal, choose DermaSafe Stretch Mark Cream & Scar Removal Therapy. It has an organic aloe base and ingredients that are deemed safe even for pregnant women.

For surgical scars, Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel is a must-try product. Apart from decreasing the appearance of your scars, it can also alleviate itching and pain.

If you’re looking for a solution for your old scars, we recommend Selevax Intensive Scar Cream. Although a bit expensive, it can deliver results in as early as 3 weeks, depending on how severe your scars are.

2017 Reviews of The Best Scar Removal Creams

#1 Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream

Mederma PM

Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream is specifically formulated for night use to assist in the skin’s natural repair process at night. It promises to let you see results in just 14 days.

Exciting, right?

Well, that’s not the only nice thing about the product. The cream also has Tripeptol, a formula that utilizes peptides, collagen and antioxidants to prevent free radical damage.

Free radicals, in case you are wondering, can cause premature skin aging and serious health conditions, like cancer.

The product is both sold in jars and tubes. However, as exposure to air and light can greatly decrease the effectiveness of antioxidants, buy one that comes in a tube packaging.

Apart from preserving the product, the packaging can also make dispensing a whole lot easier and less messy.

The cream’s main ingredient is dimethicone, which is greatly known for its healing abilities. It is partnered with onion extracts and a handful of amino acids to get the job done.

For consistency, the product is a light cream. Although fit for all skin types, I suggest you still do a patch test just to make sure.

The cream contains alcohol, which is considered potentially irritating to those with extra sensitive skin.

What We Like:

  • Contains great ingredients to promote skin healing and repair
  • Works quickly
  • Reasonable priced for its formulation

What We Didn’t Like:

  • Contains alcohol
  • May not work right away with old scars

#2 Evanesce Advanced Scar and Blemish Treatment

Natura Science Labs

Great for both new and old scars, Evanesce Advanced Scar and Blemish Treatment can also be used on stretch marks and surgery scars. It is packed with natural extracts, like kelp, aloe vera and white curcumin to deliver its claims.

Apart from the wonderful list of ingredients, the product also has vitamin B3 and collagen to boost your skin and make it look plumper.

With the combination of these ingredients, the cream is effective in replacing old and dull cells with healthier ones.

The product is recommended to be used twice a day. During the morning, make sure that you’re wearing a sunscreen or sun protective gears.

UV rays can make your scars look more pigmented that they are, especially with constant exposure. If you still haven’t invested in one yet, we have a list of sunscreens you might want to check out.

The cream has a brownish color, so don’t be surprised. It’s not a sign of a bad product or batch.

Despite not having the best color and consistency for a scar removal cream, it actually isn’t bad smelling.

Another issue you might encounter with this cream is its consistency. It tends to clump which can make application a bit of an issue, particularly if you’ll be wearing makeup on top of it.

What We Like:

  • Contains natural extracts
  • Can work on old scars, too
  • Great for almost all types of scars

What We Didn’t Like:

  • Clumpy and tends to flake off
  • Color can be off-putting
  • A bit pricey

#3 DermaSafe Stretch Mark Cream & Scar Removal Therapy


DermaSafe Stretch Mark Cream & Scar Removal Therapy has an organic aloe base. Apart from that, the cream also has Cucumber and Wood Mallow to maintain or boost your skin's moisture and to aid in its natural repair process.

Despite the moisture it offers, this product has a non-greasy formulation. You won’t have to worry about feeling sticky or tacky after application.

The nice thing about this product is that it can’t only address scars. It can also soothe stretch marks and even pregnant women can safely use it.

Take note that the cream is paraben-free, too.

To get the most out of the product, it’s recommended that you use it twice a day. Massage it on your skin until it gets fully absorbed.

The cream comes with a subtle scent. It’s not really that bothersome as it only becomes noticeable during application.

What We Like:

  • Has a non greasy formulation
  • Absorbs quickly
  • Leaves skin moisturized
  • Great for stretch marks, too
  • Contains a generous amount of product

What We Didn’t Like:

  • Scent can be an issue for some people
  • Can take time to work

#4 Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel

Kelo-Cote Advanced Formula Scar Gel has a unique name. Despite this, the product is no joke when it comes to effects.

In fact, it’s physician recommended when it comes to alleviating the itching and discomforts that come with scarring. Apart from the relief you can get from this product, it can also greatly diminish the appearance of your scars.

It contains 100% silicone to get all these things done.

And if you are wondering how effective this product is, it’s actually used by people who underwent surgery, like cleft lip, breast augmentation and other procedures.

One thing to take note, however, is that it may not deliver quick results, especially if you’ll be using it on old scars. You may have to use it longer and more frequently (twice a day) to get the results you are looking for.

For its small size, this one can be an expensive investment.

Things We Liked

  • Works great on surgical scars
  • Helps relieve itching and pain
  • Great on new scars

Things We Didn't Like

  • May take a while to work on old scars
  • Expensive

#5 Selevax Intensive Scar Cream

This scar removal cream is packed with antioxidants, such as Vitamin E, that can help improve blood flow to your scar tissues. It also has dimethicone and glycerin to soften and moisturize the skin.

Aside from these components, this Selevax cream also has Vitamin C which is known to help minimize hyperpigmentation of the skin. The cream also has Rosehip Seed oil, Sunflower oil and shea butter.

This combination of ingredients allows the product to work as fast as 3 weeks, depending on how severe your scars are. This time frame nearly coincides with the skin’s normal turnover rate of 27 days.

Selevax Intensive Scar Cream claims to address both old and new scars. If you’ll be using it for a scar you acquired years ago, the effects might not be visible right away.

However, with religious application, most reviewers were able to get the results they want. Some of them even noted seeing improvements on fresh acne scars in just two to three days.

The texture of the product is creamy, but it gets absorbed into the skin quick. Most reviewers like that the cream doesn’t have any discernable scent.

Things We Liked

  • Works on both old and new scars
  • Doesn’t have fragrance
  • Has both antioxidants and essential fatty acids

Things We Didn't Like

  • Can take up time to work if used on old scars
  • Can be expensive

Reviews and Comparisons of The Best Scar Removal Cream


Best Overall

2nd choice

3rd choice

4th choice

5th choice

Top-Rated Scar Removal Cream 2017

Mederma PM
Natura Science Labs


Mederma PM

Natura Science Labs




Key Ingredients


Natural extracts, vitamin B3 and collagen

Aloe, Cucumber, Wood mallows and peptides

100% silicone

Rose hip seed oil, orange oil, shea butter, cocoa butter and more

Texture/ Consistency













1 oz

1 oz

4 oz

10 grams

1 oz







Get Started

What Causes Scars?

Having acne-scarred skin can be enough to make you feel intimidated or even too conscious about yourself. And if you’ve ever tried using concealers and cover-ups, you’ll know what I’m talking about.

Despite looking odd, scarring is actually a part of the body’s normal healing process. It is your body’s attempt to repair or replace lost or damaged skin.

You can get it from any of the following:

  • Direct injuries to the skin, such as accidental wounds and surgeries
  • Inflammation of the skin
  • Infection of the skin and underlying tissues

Generally, scars are made of fibrous tissues. To a certain extent, these tissues can be structurally different from your normal skin.

This is one good reason why they vary in appearance, color, and even depth. Some scars can be more prominent than others while some can come with pain and itchiness.

Factors that can affect how scars will look like include the type and location of injury as well as its direction. Your age, nutritional status and gender can also play important parts.

Even your skin color can affect the way your skin reacts after an injury. Those that have darker skin color are more prone to not only scars but keloids as well.

This brings me to...​

The Four Types of Scars

There are several types of scars. However, to cut the long list short, we’ve categorized them into four major groups.

Depressed or Atrophic Scars​

This type of scar is commonly seen among acne sufferers and those who have contracted chicken pox. Depressed scars, as the name implies, have sunken and pitted appearance.

They are the most frequent type of scar you can encounter. It develops when the supporting structures of the skin, like the fats and muscles, get permanently damaged or lost.​

To subcategorize, there are several types of depressed scars.

  • Boxcar scars have defined and steeper edges
  • Ice pick scars, on the other hand, involve narrow and deep indentions on the skin. They are generally the hardest type of atrophic scars to remedy or treat.
  • Rolling scars are typically more visible among aging skin because there’s a decrease in elasticity. This type of scar has rounded and sloping edges.

Hypertrophic and Keloid Scars

Keloid scars involve scar tissues that develop beyond the affected area. Hypertrophic scars, on the other hand, involve tissue growths that are confined to a specific spot on your skin.​

While hypertrophic scars can develop within weeks of the injury, keloids can form up to a year after healing. As mentioned, keloid scars are also more common among dark-skinned people.​

Both of these scars can appear from red to brown in color. They are thicker than other scars and are elevated from the skin.​​

Contracture Scars

​Contracture scars often develop after a burn injury, especially second and third degree burns. Other than your skin, these scars can also tighten your muscles and tissues which can impair your ability to move.

Stretch Marks​

Stretch marks are technically scars that develop in the dermal layer of the skin. Although it’s a common notion that stretch marks occur because of overstretching, hormonal changes as well as genetics are also considered as major factors for its development.​​

What Makes The Best Scar Removal Cream?​

​​Scar creams are considered as the least invasive and more affordable means of addressing scars. Although most of them are effective, not all creams can work really well.

In looking for the best scar removal cream, we suggest using the following criteria:​

  • Reversing scars can’t happen overnight. If a product sounds too good to be true, it’s best to let it go.
  • A good scar cream should be able to increase your skin’s collagen production in sync with your skin's normal cellular turnover rate.
  • It should be able to reduce itching and pain, if there are any.
  • It should contain natural ingredients.
  • It’s also good if you can find a cream that’s enriched with the essential vitamins and minerals to revive and maintain your skin’s health and integrity.


No scar removal cream can work like magic overnight. Because scars are tougher than your normal skin tissues, it can take some time before they can respond to topical treatments.

It’s not enough that you buy and use the best scar removal cream. The right method and frequency of application are essential factors that you must also consider.

However, because we’re aware of how damaging scars are to your self-esteem, we want to lift the hard work off of your hands, and present the most effective product for you. In this case, it’s the Mederma PM Intensive Overnight Scar Cream.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 2 comments