The Best Eyeliner for Oily Skin - 2017 Reviews and Top Picks

In our commitment to provide you with only the best products that’ll suit your skin type, we have gathered and reviewed 5 of the top eyeliners making a buzz in the makeup scene today. We then picked what we feel is the best eyeliner for oily skin based on type, ease of application, lasting power and its affordability.

Perfectionists will also love the Eyestudio Master Precise Liquid Liner, Black by Maybelline New York. With its 0.4mm brush tip, create the sharpest design you can think of minus the hassle.

Long-wearing, it is a smudge-proof eyeliner that delivers precise lines with just a single stroke.

Choose the Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner, Black Ink by Bobbi Brown for something award-winning. Featured in several magazines, this is super long lasting and is humidity and water-resistant.

Perfectionists would love Kat Von D’s Tattoo Liner, Trooper liquid liner. Designed to create super-fine lines, this liner is a must-have for beauty pros or even for those new to makeup.

Highly-pigmented, it is a waterproof eyeliner that promises to last all day.

For a highly-pigmented look, go for the Dolly Wink Liquid Eyeliner, Deep Black by Koji. It also contains honey extracts that moisturizes and cares for your lids while making you look beautiful.

Fans of the gel liner should try the Pro Longwear Fluidline, Blacktrack by MAC. Applied with a brush, this liner claims to provide the same precision of liquid liners.

2017’s Reviews of the Best Eyeliners for Oily Skin

Rankings

Brands

Type

Quantity

Editor’s Rating

#1

Maybelline New York

Liquid

0.037 ounces

#2

Bobbi Brown

Gel

0.1 ounces

#3

Kat Von D

Liquid

0.019 ounces

#4

Koji

Liquid

-

#5

MAC

Gel

0.1 ounces

Find out what our editors think is the best eyeliner for oily skin and discover what your next makeup product must-have in this list.

#1- Eyestudio Master Precise Liquid Liner, Black by Maybelline New York

Maybelline New York

This is the best mascara and eyeliner for oily skin as it was the 2013’s Allure Best of Beauty Award winner. With a title like that, how can we contest?

This product takes pride in its 0.4mm precision brush. Having a brush as precise as this is perfect even for beginners or for those intimidated by liquid liners.

It delivers precise definition with just a single stroke, which means you won’t have to spend time and effort in doing your liner. Plus, it also means that it’ll save you lots of money.

This is definitely the new generation of liquid liner. It makes use of two technologies that are exclusive to them, namely the ink technology and the spring cap.

The former keeps pigments bold and intense, while the latter keeps the formula fresh.

Fragrance-free, this can be used even by those with skin sensitivity. It is also ophthalmologist tested, and is suitable for those with sensitive eyes or those who wear contact lenses.

A lot of reviewers have stated that this is their go-to eyeliner. Since it comes in pen form, so those intimidated by liquid liners could drop their pencil liners and give this one a shot.

Some even stated that this product is comparable to the pricier ones they’ve tried. This product does what it’s supposed to, and is definitely a cheaper drugstore alternative.

What We Like:

  • Comes in pen form
  • Fragrance-free
  • Long-wearing
  • Waterproof

What We Didn’t Like:

  • Contains parabens
  • Can be difficult to remove
  • Can dry up quickly

#2- Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner, Black Ink by Bobbi Brown

Bobbi Brown

Because it can give a water-resistant finish, this product is the best eyeliner waterline oily skin. It also glides on smoothly and precisely, making it perfect for that delicate eye area.

A true original, it offers the precision of liquid liners and the ease of gel-based formulas. Highly waterproof, it offers 12 hours of humidity- and sweat- resistant wear.

Those who fear using gel liners should give this product a try. It is fairly easy to work with—just make sure to work quickly as it tends to dry easily.

What makes this product really great is that it doesn’t wear out easily unlike other gel liners. It also provides a beautiful matte finish, perfect for those with oily skin.

This gel liner is perfect for those who hate touch-ups. It literally lasts the whole day and has a velvety texture that comes with it.

Lastly, this product is completely buildable until you reach your desired line depth. There are also no issues about blinking or runs, which is usually the problem with liquid liners.

What We Like:

  • Waterproof
  • Long-wearing
  • Pigmented
  • Smudgable

What We Didn’t Like:

  • Can be expensive
  • Eyeliner brush sold separately
  • Dries quickly

#3- Tattoo Liner, Trooper by Kat Von D

Kat Von D

This is the best liquid eyeliner for oily skin because of its 24 hour-wear formula. We know how frustrating it is to find a makeup for this skin type, so having this one is a gem.

Highly-pigmented, this product boasts of its precision brush tips that comprises of over 325 flexible bristles. With this in hand, you can easily turn from a newbie to a pro in no time.

This product is key in creating the most intricate and most detailed “eye art” you could imagine. It allows for an easy and effortless application to recreate that look you’ve always wanted.

Another great thing about this product is that its tip will not fray. We think this is perfect because you don’t want your final look looking sloppy and looking like it’s done by a child.

It’s not surprising that this liner is a cult favorite. It really lasts all day and its color does not fade, so for those who isn’t confident in using a liquid liner, this is strongly recommended.

This liner is completely vegan. This means that what you’re putting into your skin is completely safe and is free from any toxic chemicals.

Most importantly, this eyeliner is waterproof. It is also run-, crack-, melt-, and fade-resistant, and according to a customer, no amount of tears can wipe this baby out.

What We Like:

  • Precise tip
  • Bold color
  • Long-wearing
  • Waterproof
  • Comes off easily with makeup remover
  • Cruelty-free
  • Completely vegan

What We Didn’t Like:

  • Is a bit pricey
  • Using it can be a hassle (not really buildable)
  • Can dry up easily
  • Not “tattoo-like”

#4- Dolly Wink Liquid Eyeliner, Deep Black by Koji

Koji

What makes this the best eyeliner for oily skin is that it’s extremely water-resistant. It clings to the skin the moment you apply it, so if you hate waiting for your liner to dry, this one’s for you.

The color of this liner also doesn’t fade overtime. This means your liner would stay strong and vivid all day long.

This product also comes in an ink-brush tip. This gives you more control as you try to create delicate or bold lines to complete your look.

Created by Japanese model Tsubasa Masuwaka, it promises beautiful, big, and doll-like eyes with every application. It dramatically highlights the eyes with its deep and rich black pigment.

This liquid eyeliner is also a real time and money saver. Because it is highly-pigmented, one application of it already looks like a double application.

It also contains honey extracts, something which is a rare find these days. It moisturizes and gently cares for your lids while working double time to make you look beautiful.

The brush on this liner is firm yet flexible enough which makes it easy to make thin winged liner sections. We think that the brush is really great as it allows you to easily get precise lines.

Another thing is that it can be washed off easily. It is also perfect for those with hooded eyelids, and can last you the whole day even without an eyeshadow primer.

What We Like:

  • Waterproof
  • Long-wearing
  • Cute packaging
  • Bold color

What We Didn’t Like:

  • Not cruelty-free
  • Can dry out easily
  • Brush easily messes up

#5- Pro Longwear Fluidline, Blacktrack by MAC

MAC

Its non-acnegenic and smudge-proof qualities make this the best eyeliner for oily skin. Dermatologist and ophthalmologist tested, your eyes are surely free from any harmful toxins.

This gel liner is really long-wearing. It stays put for up to 8 hours, making it a perfect choice for that long night out with friends.

Softer and silkier, this product promises the precision of a liquid liner with its dip-and-stroke action. It also has a bold color, great for those days when you really want to make a statement.

According to a customer, this product also doubles as an eyeshadow. Though she uses a different shade for that, if you’re looking for versatility, this product is it.

Another great thing about this product is that a little goes a long way. It would take more than 6 months for it to finish, so you definitely get your money’s worth with this one.

People with oily skin would love that this product leaves a matte finish. Almost anything that makes us look shine-free is definitely a must-have.

What we really love about this product is that it is really buildable. Though it is also great for making thin lines, the fact that it is easy to build makes it perfect for creating a dramatic look.

What We Like:

  • Comes in gel form
  • Long-wearing
  • Waterproof
  • A little goes a long way

What We Didn’t Like:

  • Not as pigmented as it claims to be
  • Brush is sold separately
  • Can dry quickly
  • Formula gets thicker with time

Reviews and Comparisons of the Best Eyeliners for Oily Skin

Rankings

Best Overall

2nd choice

3rd choice

4th choice

5th choice

Top-Rated Best Eyeliners for Oily Skin 2017

Maybelline New York
Bobbi Brown
Kat Von D
Koji
MAC

Brand

Maybelline New York

Bobbi Brown

Kat Von D

Koji

MAC

Easy to apply

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Long-wearing

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Waterproof

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Get Started

A Beginner’s Guide To Eyeliners

With a lot of eyeliner types available in the market, choosing the one that’ll suit you best can both be overwhelming and petrifying.

For most of us, it’s probably the latter.

It is confusing, but once you’ve found the one, you’ll be set to conquer the world (not to be taken literally.) Below is everything you need to know about eyeliners to narrow down your choices.

Pencil liners are the type recommended for beginners. They’re easier to handle than their gel or liquid counterparts, and are a good start if you don’t have a steady hand.

Wax-based pencils are common, and come in a mechanical pencil that you twist or in a wooden pencil that you sharpen. They’re perfect for a natural look or for lining the inner rims of the eye.

Winged eyes are also achievable, but the result isn’t as sharp because of the method of application. Kohl pencils, which are smoother and softer, are easy to smudge but fade off easily.

For a bold and sharp look, liquid liners are for you. They dry quickly and won’t smudge easily, but to be able to use them, you’ll need A LOT of practice and the steadiest hand.

They often come in a tube with a felt tip or brush applicator, and as of present, marker-style liquid liners are now available. This is the type for you if you’re going for a winged liner look.

Cream or gel liners are known for being easy to build up or smudge for a smoky effect. Great for dramatic or subtle looks, they’re versatile, smooth, and are known for their lasting power.

A gel liner usually comes in a pot and makes use of a brush as an applicator, and they typically take a couple of seconds to set and last throughout the day.

Ok, so what is the best type for oily skin?

Liquid gel liners are recommended for those with oily skin. Since they dry pretty quick, they won’t smudge as compared to pencil eyeliners.

Just see to it that the brand you choose promises longevity.

Makeup Tips for Oily Eyelids​

Below are 4 simple tips to help stop eyeliner going in places where it isn’t supposed to be in:​

  • Never use concealer and foundation as an eyelid primer. It’ll only make it easy for the eyeliner to smudge into the eyelid crease because of their creamy formulations.                                                                                                                       Exceptions to the rule are if you’re using a water-based product, or if you’re using a powder or mineral foundation.
  • Be cautious in choosing eyeliners, and avoid smudge-y liners such as Kohl liners. Gel liners work best for oily lids, as they won’t budge unless removed.
  • Set your liner with an eyeshadow powder if you insist in using pencil eyeliners. What this does is it will absorb the oil from the liner to stop it from smudging into the crease.
  • Never forget to set. This helps in keeping the lids smudge-free, but just make sure to have a light hand as you don’t want your lids to end up looking cakey.

Conclusion

We believe that having the perfect eye makeup is key to your look. While eyshadows are optional, eyeliners are a must if you want a dramatic look and make a statement.

The same thing goes if you want a more natural look but don’t want to go through your whole makeup regimen.

But things become tricky if you have oily lids. If you love makeup but have oily lids, you really need a miracle so that your eye makeup stays in place.

This is why we’ve chosen Maybelline New York’s Eye Studio Master Precise Liquid Eyeliner as this roundup’s best eyeliner for oily skin. Great for oily lids, applying it is a breeze and it lasts all day.

It also doesn’t smudge easily and end up running. But since it’s a liquid eyeliner, you really have to have steady hands to achieve the perfect look.​

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments