The Best Undereye Concealer - 2017 Reviews and Top Picks

“In our commitment to help you find products that can actually live up to their claims, we are presenting this list of the best undereye concealers after spending more than 18 hours reviewing 19 different brands. The products that made it into our list were carefully picked out based on coverage, longevity and price so you’re assured that they can give you more than your money’s worth”

At A Glance: Our Choices for The Best Undereye Concealers

NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer offers full coverage and a formulation that's free from parabens. It's non-comedogenic, too.

This concealer is great for those with oily skin but may not be the right match for those with extremely dry skin.

For an affordable option in concealing dark undereye circles, E.L.F. Under Eye Concealer and Highlighter is highly recommended. For its price, you'll get two products already.

Apart from that it's infused with vitamins, it also has caffeine and green tea to make your eyes look more awake.

NYX Cosmetics Dark Circle Concealer offers full coverage. It promises to conceal your dark circles by neutralizing it with an orange hue.

Take note that the product contains coconut oil which can be an issue for those with oily skin.

For a brightening and instant cooling effect, you might want to consider checking Almay Wake Up Undereye Concealer. It has a moisturizing formula to help you avoid caking and settling into fine lines.

Bare Minerals Stroke of Light Eye Brightener is an illuminator and undereye concealer in one. It has a thin texture that goes smoothly and easily on the skin.

It can give your undereye area a good lift without making you look all sparkly and glittery.

2017’s Reviews of The Best Undereye Concealers





Editor’s Rating



0.22 oz

Tube with applicator


e.l.f. Cosmetics

0.34 ounce

Dual-ended tube with applicators



0.1 ounce




0.22 fluid ounce

Tube with brush tip


Bare Escentuals

0.28 ounce

Tube with applicator

#1 NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer


NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer has a long-lasting formulation that won’t crease up. It’s perfect for those people with oily skin looking for an effective product to conceal their dark under eye circles.


The concealer is paraben-free and noncomedogenic. It doesn’t even have alcohol and fragrance to fit those with sensitive skin, too.

The product promises to instantly diminish signs of tiredness as well as fine lines with its hydrating and brightening benefits. Apart from cover up, it can also give you a softer and smoother complexion.

It is a thick concealer which can provide full coverage. Because it’s thick, it’s fairly easy to put too much product and end up making your eye area look cakey.

However, with proper application, this concealer can easily be anyone’s holy grail makeup product.

It’s fast drying and extremely blendable.

What We Like:

  • Noncomedogenic
  • Offers full coverage
  • Easy to apply

What We Didn’t Like:

  • Expensive
  • Not hydrating enough for extremely dry skin

#2 E.L.F. Under Eye Concealer and Highlighter

e.l.f. Cosmetics

Infused with vitamins A and E, E.L.F. Under Eye Concealer and Highlighter promises to soothe and tighten your undereye area to make it look more lifted. Apart from the said vitamins, you can also find chamomile, caffeine and green tea in its list of ingredients.

It has a thin consistency which you won’t find hard to blend on your skin. It has a doe-foot applicator for easier and more controlled application.

The concealer doesn’t crease up that much. In fact, setting it with a powder or using a primer can give you a virtually crease-free result.

As for the highlighter, it has the same consistency as the concealer. You are supposed to apply it on top of the concealer for a more lifted look.

It is, however, whitish in color, which is kind of intimidating to use. Make sure you blend everything properly to avoid having an awkward white cast under your eyes.

What We Like:

  • 2-in-1 product
  • Doesn’t cake up
  • Has vitamins and extracts
  • Easy to blend
  • Very affordable

What We Didn’t Like:

  • Only offers light to medium coverage
  • Highlighter may not work on everyone

#3 NYX Cosmetics Dark Circle Concealer


For a full coverage under eye concealer, NYX Cosmetics Dark Circle Concealer is a must-try product. It utilizes orange pigments to help neutralize the darkness in your undereye area, especially those that have blue and purple hues.

One thing that makes this product interesting is that it is formulated with coconut oil. Its texture feel quite dense, but once warmed up, you’ll actually feel its emollient texture.

Because of its ingredients, you should expect the concealer to be creamy and quite tricky to get out of the pot.

One issue I have with this product is that it tends to settle on fine lines. It feels a bit oily on the skin, too.

I find setting the concealer right away helps prevent it from budging. Be careful though, as patting in too much product can make your undereye look clumpy.

What We Like:

  • Offers full coverage
  • Has an orange tint to neutralize darkness
  • Affordable

What We Didn’t Like:

  • Oily finish
  • Tends to cling on fine lines
  • Orange tint may not work on every skin tone

#4 Almay Wake Up Undereye Concealer


Promising to reduce the appearance of dark circles and make your eyes look less puffy, Almay Wake Up Undereye Concealer is infused with cucumber, aloe vera and green tea extracts. These ingredients are known to have hydrating benefits to freshen up your eye area.

In addition to concealing dark circles, the product can also provide instant cooling effect.

The concealer has a creamy texture that doesn’t look cakey at all. It’s very smooth and glides seamlessly on the skin.

One issue you’ll probably encounter with this product is its packaging which includes a built-in brush applicator. Although the idea is great, it just won’t fit, especially with how creamy the product is.

The concealer tends to get stuck on the brush part. And when you squeeze the product, it will cause the tube to crack or the top part to blow out.

As for coverage, the product can only provide sheer to medium coverage. It has a fluid texture and a mild brightening effect to help you look more awake.

What We Like:

  • Has a moisturizing formula
  • Doesn’t cake on the skin
  • Has subtle luminosity

What We Didn’t Like:

  • Built-in brush applicator makes application difficult
  • Only has sheer to medium coverage

#5 Bare Minerals Stroke of Light Eye Brightener

 Bare Escentuals

If you are on a hurry or just feeling lazy, Bare Minerals Stroke of Light Eye Brightener would be a great concealer for you. The product provides sheer to medium coverage and has an illuminating effect to brighten up your eye area.

The concealer comes with its own doe foot applicator which helps you seamlessly apply the product on your skin. My problem with this type of applicator is that it isn’t hygienic.

Dipping the applicator in and out of the tube can mean contamination of the product.

As for consistency, it’s in between thick and watery. It applies smoothly on the skin and is easy to pat and blend.

It’s lightweight, too.

The concealer isn’t heavy duty which means it may not be enough to cover extremely dark eye circles. If this sounds exactly like your case, you might want to consider the other products on this list.

With products that have illuminating effects, it’s easy to feel overwhelmed about looking sparkly and shiny. With this concealer, however, you won’t have any issues with that.

It’s actually great in making your eyes look less tired, especially if you wear eyeglasses which tend to accentuate dark circles more.

What We Like:

  • A concealer and illuminator in one
  • Does not settle on fine lines
  • Lightweight

What We Didn’t Like:

  • May not be enough for really dark circles
  • Expensive

Reviews and Comparisons of The Best Undereye Concealers


Best Overall

2nd choice

3rd choice

4th choice

5th choice

Top-Rated Best Undereye Concealers 2017

e.l.f. Cosmetics
 Bare Escentuals



e.l.f. Cosmetics



Bare Escentuals









Light to medium


Sheer to medium

Sheer to medium







Get Started

How To Conceal Dark Circles

Dark circles can be caused by a number of things.

They can be due to your genetics or your blood vessels swelling and not draining properly. These things can be aggravated by not having enough sleep, eating too much salty food and the presence of allergies.​

No matter what the cause is, one thing is clear. Dark circles aren’t pretty, especially if they come with puffiness.

Now, as for concealing, the process can sound a little daunting. But, once you get the hang of it, it’s actually really easy.

For dark circles, it’s a good idea to use orange tinted concealers since they help neutralize any bluish or purplish discolorations. The skin around your eyes are thin so it’s easy for the color of your veins to be slightly visible.

Once the concealer has been blended, apply another concealer on top of it. This time, it should be the color of your skin.

Apply your concealer by mimicking an inverted triangle. This helps brighten up your under eyes, instead of highlighting your problem area.

If your eye bags are puffy, considering using a small angled brush and apply the concealer on the shadow or crease of your eye bags. For this trick, make sure you are using a concealer that perfectly matches your skin tone- else, it will look odd.

Use your ring finger when blending the concealer as it is your weakest finger. It can blend the product without putting too much pressure on your skin.

You can go straight to setting your concealer. But, for an extra lift, you can apply another layer of concealer, using a product that’s one shade lighter than your skin.

This extra step can help give your eye area a brighter effect.

Set the concealer using a translucent powder. For dry skin, you can use an eyeshadow that is two shades lighter than your skin.

Setting your concealer can help prevent creasing throughout the day.

Extra Tips On How To Remedy Dark Circles​

The way you take care of your skin, especially the delicate parts under your eyes, is as essential as choosing the right concealer for coverage. Remember, the makeup you apply can only get better if you have a flawless beige.

Prior to applying your concealer, you’ll need to depuff your eye bags. Using frozen tea bags or chilled spoon on your eyes for a couple of minutes can help reduce the swelling.

Using an eye mask frequently can also help correct your dark under eyes.

If you are not having proper rest or if you are too stressed, work on getting to bed early and make sure you get a deep sleep. This is the phase of your sleep that facilitates the repair of your damaged muscles and cells.​

Make it a habit to use an eye cream, too. Do not wait until you see fine lines appearing on your eye area before you kickstart any anti-aging regimen.

The earlier you start, the slower the aging process can show on your skin.


Like pimple marks, dark under eyes can also be embarrassing. They can make you look tired, even though you’re actually not.

Because we know how it feels, we’re recommending NARS Radiant Creamy Concealer as the best under eye concealer. It offers full coverage and ease of application.

We also have a detailed buying guide about Best Non-Creasing Concealer and Best Concealer For Fine Lines And Wrinkles in case you want to check out​

When concealing dark under eyes, the last thing you want to happen is for your concealer to cling to your lines and make your problem areas more noticeable than they already are. This is exactly why this product is a must-try- it’s hydrating and creamy.​

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments