Best Eyeliner

Best Eyeliner

For makeup enthusiasts, eyeliners are essential in finalizing any look they create. If you are one of these people, then this list is great news for you. We have done the hard work of reviewing the best eyeliners that have been making noises in the industry so you wouldn’t have to risk your skin, look and even your money. We’ve categorized them based on criteria we feel are most valuable to you.

Looking for the best eyeliner?

Eyeliners can give your eyes the definition they need. Unfortunately, however, not all eyeliners are formulated the same way. Others aren’t long lasting while some can smudge and ruin your entire makeup. With this in mind, we’ve put together a list of the best eyeliners worth giving a try. Select a category from the list and see our most recommended products.

Eyeliner - Top 1 Favorites

Rankings

Brand

Editor's Rating

Award

Price

#1

Maybelline

When you have oily skin, you’d know how difficult it is to keep your eyeliners stay long. Because we understand this frustration, we decided to review and test out the best eyeliner for oily skin today. They were carefully chose based on longevity, ease of application and formulation- so you wouldn’t have to worry about smudging or fading anymore.

Eyestudio Master Precise Liquid Liner, Black by Maybelline New York

Maybelline

Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner, Black Ink by Bobbi Brown

Bobbi Brown

Kat Von D’s Tattoo Liner, Trooper

  

Kat Von D

How To Choose The Right Type of Eyeliner For You

Whether you’re a pro or a beginner in makeup, choosing the right eyeliner is always a tough job. There are tons of things you need to consider, like shades, finish and longevity.

But, perhaps, one of the first things you need to take into consideration is the type of eyeliner. Each type has its own pros and cons and we’ll break down the details for you.

Gel liners

Gel liners have a waxy consistency. They are likely to be waterproof and they’ll stay put for several hours.

Because of their consistency, the best way to apply gel liners is by using an eyeliner brush. It will give you more control and precision during application.

They are great to use on the waterline since they’re waterproof. The problem with this is that gel liners can be a bit difficult to apply on that area.

You can easily end up with red and teary eyes.

Another issue is its application. They have a tendency to cause skin tugging which isn’t really great if you want to keep fine lines and wrinkles away.

Pencil eyeliners

If you are looking for a versatile eyeliner, this one’s it. You can use it for tightlining, on your waterline and in creating a cat-eye effect.

They aren’t that long-lasting. Even those waterproof ones can only last a few hours on the skin.

Retractable eyeliners

Retractable eyeliners are just like your pencil liners. The only difference is that they don’t require sharpening.

You just need to twist the barrel of the liner until the product pops up.

Liquid eyeliners

When it comes to staying power, liquid eyeliners are your best bet. However, unlike the other types, this one can’t be smudged.

You can’t even apply it on your water line.

It also requires a steady hand. This is one good reason why liquid liners aren’t really recommended for beginners.

Liquid liners have two subtypes which refer to the type of tip they have.

Felt-tip liners are easy to control. They offer thicker liners and more precision.

Unfortunately, although they are hard to remove, they are more prone to smudging. You‘ll need to layer them, too.

The brush-tip liners, meanwhile, are great for creating sharp and thin lines. They mostly come in a matte finish and they are easy to remove.

One issue you may encounter with brush-tip liners is how they require time and precision. If you are in a hurry, this can be a nuisance.